Do trackbacks mixed with comments annoy blog readers?
Posted 15 August 2007, by Aaron

Over on Devlounge there is an excellent list of 15 design decisions that annoy readers. The article is written by Ronald Huereca and is based on informal feedback received at his personal blog the Reader Appreciation Project.
The 15 annoyances are:
- Pop-ups (link hovers)
- Turning off the timestamp on posts
- Pop-up windows
- Snap preview pop-ups
- Positioning the subscribe box above the search box
- Dark backgrounds
- Auto play music
- Not separating trackbacks from comments
- Talking advertisements
- Obtrusive subscription requests
- Hard to find subscription options
- Failure to interlink posts or show related posts
- Obtrusive advertisements
- In-text advertisements
- Small font size
I agree with pretty much every single point that Ronald makes, but the one that caught my eye is the issue of separating trackbacks from comments. Ronald’s argument is that they don’t form part of the conversation:
“To a regular commenter and/or reader of the post, the trackback is not really part of the conversation. To me, a trackback interspersed with regular comments is more of an interruption than a continuation of discussion.”
It’s certainly not the most annoying annoyance on the list, but I think Ronald has a point. And it’s actually quite common: by default WordPress displays all comments and trackbacks in chronological order, and most bloggers don’t do anything to change it.
There are a couple of ways of changing this default behaviour. If you fancy hand-editing your comment.php template file, a fairly simple technique is demonstrated on Noscope. If you’re not the coding type then the Separating Comments & Pings plugin may be for you.
Another site-tweak is added it my ‘to-do’ list…
Many thanks for the recent comments: Asgeir, 1ndigo, Johno and Mac.
Related articles:
Tags:Plugins, Web Design, WordPress

Asgeir Hoem
16 August 2007, 1:07 am